For the first time ever, the leaders of the United States, China and Russia sat down together at the same table. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin met for about an hour and a half on Thursday, November 19, on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.

The meeting produced a short joint declaration on the United Nations, energy and nuclear risk. It did not produce a breakthrough on the war in Ukraine. Here is what happened, what was agreed and what remains open.

A round table by a lake

According to Reuters, the three leaders sat at a round table in a villa set among wooded hills beside a lake in Shenzhen. They described the meeting as a historic moment, but made no immediate statements when it ended.

“We are really making history,” Trump said at the start. “No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement.”

In his opening remarks, Trump said the three countries, the world’s largest nuclear powers, were “uniquely positioned” to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons and lessen the risk of their use, as reported by AP. Experts quoted by AP had kept expectations low for major breakthroughs.

What each leader said

Putin said the three countries have “numerous shared interests in the settlement of regional conflicts, including obviously the conflict in Ukraine,” according to Reuters. He arrived fresh from a setback in the war, after a key bridge linking Crimea to Russia was crippled.

Xi called for every effort to be made to prevent nuclear war, saying nuclear weapons should be comprehensively prohibited and completely destroyed, according to The Guardian’s live coverage.

Trump also criticized the International Criminal Court, calling it “out of control,” the Guardian reported, even though Putin is the subject of an ICC arrest warrant issued in 2023.

The joint declaration

After the meeting, the Kremlin published a “Russia-China-U.S. Heads of State Declaration toward Peace.” It contains four main points:

  • As permanent members of the UN Security Council, the three countries committed to reform the UN so it can respond more effectively to global challenges.
  • They plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products and reaffirmed the importance of stable energy flows.
  • They agreed that the ICC and similar bodies “must not abuse their jurisdiction” and stressed respect for the immunities of state officials.
  • They reaffirmed that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” and said they will hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the spread of nuclear weapons.

China also issued what the Guardian described as a “peace declaration” after the talks. Trump then left China.

What it means for Ukraine

Before the summit, critics feared that three powerful leaders could make decisions about Ukraine’s future without Kyiv or Europe in the room. Based on what has been published so far, the declaration does not mention a Ukraine settlement, and no deal was announced.

Europe, meanwhile, is moving on its own track. On Wednesday the European Commission proposed a new €45 billion loan to help fill Ukraine’s funding gap for next year, which Kyiv would only need to repay after Russia pays reparations, Reuters reported. Ukraine’s allies also met in Berlin this week.

Trump and Xi’s separate meeting

Earlier on Thursday, Trump and Xi held their own bilateral meeting. China’s state media readout, summarized by the Guardian, described the relationship as “generally stable and positive.” Xi warned Washington on Taiwan and called for the two countries to work together to guard against security risks from artificial intelligence and “ensure that AI remains under human control at all times.” According to the Chinese readout, Trump said Washington “does not support Taiwan independence.”

What to watch next

  • Whether the promised nuclear-risk dialogue gets a date, a format or negotiators.
  • Any details on how the three countries plan to boost refined fuel supplies.
  • Reactions from Kyiv and European capitals to a summit held without them.
  • Whether more detailed readouts from Washington add anything to the Russian and Chinese accounts.

The bottom line

The Shenzhen meeting was a first and it delivered a symbolic joint statement, especially on nuclear weapons. But the hardest question, how to end the war in Ukraine, left the room unanswered. For now, the summit is a starting point, not a settlement.

Image: Round Table, chairs, TV monitor, conference room, 2nd floor, Studio C, Microsoft, Redmond, Washington, USA by Wonderlane via Flickr, CC0 1.0