Some hosts need a few sketches to settle in. John Mulaney walked into Studio 8H on Saturday, November 14, like he never left, because in a way he never really did.
The former Saturday Night Live writer hosted the show for the seventh time, with Phoebe Bridgers as musical guest, and critics were quick to call it one of the strongest episodes of Season 52 so far. Here is what happened.
A cold open critics actually liked
Mulaney appeared in the very first scene, playing an intelligence officer at CIA headquarters briefing a room of tech titans: Dario Amodei (Jane Wickline), Sam Altman (Ben Marshall), Peter Thiel (James Austin Johnson), Mark Zuckerberg (Andrew Dismukes) and Elon Musk (Jeremy Culhane).
His mission was to warn them about the dangers of being catfished by spies, a nod to the real-world news surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. To drive the point home, former cast member Bowen Yang made a surprise appearance as Huang, according to Gold Derby’s live recap.
The A.V. Club called it the first funny cold open the show had managed all season, and Vulture agreed it “didn’t suck,” which, by cold open standards, is high praise.
A nine-minute monologue
Mulaney then delivered a nine-minute stand-up set. “I’ve been doing a lot of work on myself over the past few years, and I’ve realized that I am happiest when I’m on television,” he joked, per NBC Insider.
He covered a lot of ground: his dad, Baby Boomers complaining about Gen Z while being just as hooked on their devices, the one toddler in every group who sounds like a hoarse old man, and a run of jokes about Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., whom Mulaney said he has known for more than a decade.
He also explained why hosting is easy for him: “I used to be a writer at this show, and one of the only difficult things about working here was dealing with the host. So it’s fun when I host, because it’s like there’s no host.”
Another New York musical
Mulaney’s signature musical sketches are an SNL tradition, and he brought a new one: “Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride.” It co-starred Bowen Yang, who appeared in character from his current Broadway role as Mary Todd Lincoln, NBC Insider reported.
The other sketches people are talking about
NBC highlighted several other standouts:
- “Plane Crash”
- “Gettin’ It Done”
- “Woodstock,” which imagined the future of Baby Boomers through the lens of the 1969 festival
- A sketch built around Ashley Padilla’s recurring character Kathy, in which Mulaney made clear he just wanted to promote the show
Phoebe Bridgers returns
Bridgers made her third appearance on the show and her second solo booking. Longtime viewers remember her 2021 performance of “I Know the End,” when she smashed her guitar on stage.
Why Mulaney keeps coming back
Mulaney wrote for SNL from 2008 to 2013 and helped create the character Stefon with Bill Hader. He is a member of the Five-Timers Club, and his previous hosting stints came in 2018, 2019, twice in 2020, 2022 and 2024. He has four Emmy wins, including one for SNL’s music and lyrics.
In his goodnights, he gave a shout-out to his friend and former coworker Simon Rich. Vulture summed up the night simply: Mulaney “delivered throughout,” and it may be the best episode of the season so far.
What’s next
Mulaney is the sixth host of Season 52, following Jalen Brunson, Dakota Johnson, Shane Gillis, Inde Navarrette and Druski. Clips from the episode, including the cold open and monologue, are available on NBC and SNL’s YouTube channel.
Sources: NBC Insider, The A.V. Club, Vulture.
Image: Vintage television via Rawpixel, CC0 1.0